| 20' | Kelman CharlieSonny Perkins  | ||
| 24' | 1-1 | Brown DajauneMarcus Harness | |
| 43' | Pratley Darren  | ||
| HT | 1 - 1 | ||
| 46' | Adams EbouThompson Liam  | ||
| 46' | Elder CallumPhillips Nathaniel | ||
| 62' | Brown JordanPratley Darren | ||
| 68' | Jackson KaydenBrown Dajaune |
| 68' | Barkhuizen TomBlackett-Taylor Corey |
| 71' | James TomJaiyesimi Diallang |
| 74' | Donley Jamie |
| 75' | Collins JamesMendez-Laing Nathaniel |
| 84' | Adams Ebou |
| 90' | Clare Sean |
| FT | 1 - 1 |
| 100' | Cooper BrandonSimpson Jack |
| 101' | Obiero ZechPerkins Sonny |
| 113' | Clare Sean  |
| AET | 1 - 1 |
| FAP | 7 - 6 |
| Venue Name: | The Breyer Group Stadium |
| Capacity: | NY |
